Wednesday, September 14, 2016

Guest Post by J: Morality and Politics - The British Version

Regular readers of this blog know my interests well – including my interest in understanding political preferences. In this entry I want to discuss a few observations I’ve had regarding British politics this week and how these observations fit within the context of Moral Foundations Theory (MFT). If you’re not familiar with MFT, take a look here to get a quick synopsis before proceeding further.

So over the last few days, Erica and I have enjoyed listening to BBC news regarding recent political events. (As an aside, casually listening/discussing commentary on British politics while driving through the beautiful countryside in rural England with nothing to do but to enjoy the view and keep the car on the left side of the road is quite an experience.) One of the big topics that has come up this week is the new Prime Minister’s (PM) controversial proposal to open new grammar schools in England. Grammar schools are basically English high schools that admit students based on ability. So for example, U.S. high school AP/honors students would probably go to Grammar schools, while the rest of the students would go to standard high schools (secondary schools). The goal – as with AP classes in the U.S. – is to sort students by ability so that they are not held back in classrooms in which teachers have to focus on a student body with a large variation in ability and thus often forced to teach to the lowest common denominator.

We inquired about this proposed policy to our tour guide – at the time we didn’t know what “grammar schools” were or why it was a controversial policy. I am paraphrasing, but he basically said something along the lines of the following: “Yes, it’s controversial, but it’s absolutely ridiculous that all students should be treated the same when they have different abilities and the real world will treat them as such later. But keep in mind we’re also in an era when everyone gets a trophy and no one is allowed to win or lose anymore.”

Notice I haven’t said anything about political parties, but I’m sure you now know whether the PM (and our tour guide) supports the Conservative or Labour Party (hint: it’s Conservative). Also, I don’t think it’s a coincidence that David Cameron (the Conservative who recently resigned as PM) was from the very area where we were touring – nor that our guide was also from that area!

Now – what would the Labour Party’s response to this proposal be? Obviously they’re going to be against the proposal – but what will they accuse the Conservative Party of? Remember that the Labour Party’s value system tends to sacralize victim groups. Thus, that will force them to see this proposal as a form of bigotry. And sure enough, Labour Party member Angela Rayner was quoted as saying in response: “Where once under Labour we had ‘education, education, education,’ this Government’s mantra is ‘segregation, segregation, segregation.’”


So what do we make of all of this? For me, the interesting takeaway is that politics is fundamentally the same in England as it is in the U.S – and it’s so easy to predict how people will behave and what they will think. The issues are different and the people are different. But the morality, the politics, and the non-political preferences that go along with these views are exactly the same. There’s a reason you see people flying the flag of England in the Cotswolds all over the place, but never in London (at least I didn’t see it). There’s a reason you probably won’t see a woman with a profanity-laden purse walking around the Costswolds like I did in London. And there’s a reason you won’t see much diversity in the Cotswolds with respect to food, music, entertainment, etc, like you will in London. These are fundamentally different cultures. And it’s fascinating to experience them and to notice the striking parallels between these cultures and their counterparts in the U.S. If I had more time, I would write a survey and start collecting data!

No comments:

Post a Comment